15 Best Rated Electric Fireplace Insert Reviews And Guide

Getting the best rated electric fireplace insert is the solution to most of the hassles regarding the heating. Either it piling wood for your burning insert or facing any issues in the ventilation of heat, you’ll be at ease with comfy warmth. Also, it can be a way to reduce your ecological footprint on the environment.

It will save you from all the hassles of stockpiling, venting issues, smoke and ash problems, and cleaning requirements. You can easily add an electric insert to your existing fireplace by adequately measuring the dimensions. ClassicFlame 36″ Traditional Built-in Electric Fireplace is our top recommendation in this regard, while PuraFlame Western Electric Fireplace Insert is the best budget option.

How to choose the best and most realistic electric fireplace insert?

Having a ventless electric fireplace insert is a great idea to beautify your room or lounge. But it should be compatible with your living space. Here we’ve mentioned some factors that you need to check before buying any best rated electric fireplace insert.

1. Heating Capacity

Before buying any insert, check the BTU’s and heating area of the product. Then cross-check them with your desired room. For Example, 400 sq. ft. heating capability is sufficient for a small space but won’t heat a large room or lounge. Check your heating requirements and then proceed towards buying a unit.

2. Flame Effects

The second main requirement to check is the quality of flame effects. How many numbers of colors are present? Is the brightness adjustable? Is an auto-color changing feature present? You have to do an in-depth analysis of the product in this domain before buying any product.

3. Safety Functions

The presence of useful safety features is a must for an electric fireplace insert. For Example, there must be an overheat protection system, a built-in timer function, a thermostat for temperature maintained and plug safety assurance. Also, certification from CSA and ETL would be a plus.

4. Your Place of Installation

Before buying a product, you need to understand that either the product will fit in your desired opening or not. You properly need to cross-check the product dimensions and your area of installation. Some inserts have different front and back measurements, while others have a complete square way. If you’re unaware of the measuring process, check our following guide.
How To Measure For Electric Fireplace Insert?

15 Best Rated Electric Fireplace Insert Reviews

We’ve already described the necessary factors to consider before buying an electric fireplace insert. Now, here are some reviews of top-notch products that we’ve gathered after extensive research to recommend the best one. Generally, there are three ideas concerning electric fireplace insert. 
1. Built-In Electric Fireplace Insert
2. Plug-In Electric Fireplace Insert
3. Electric Fire Log Insert
Here is a detailed guide of these products, along with some product reviews in the respective dimension.

5 Best Built In Electric Fireplace Insert Reviews

Before proceeding towards the best products, we’d like you to brief a little about builder boxes or built-in fireplace inserts. Their main point of differentiation from other inserts is that it requires a special box, mantle, or cabinet inside the wall.

Also, their heating capacity is much high than plug-in inserts or logs. Moreover, they’re a bit expensive due to the blower present inside. But great in terms of adding beauty and warming the room.  So, let us proceed towards the best rated electric fireplace insert in the built-in category.

1. ClassicFlame 36″ Traditional Built-in Electric Fireplace (Our Top Pick)

ClassicFlame 36″ traditional built-in electric fireplace is our top priority for the best rated electric fireplace insert. This builder box is a real game-changer because of various compelling features. First of all, the 89000 BTU’s heater can heat an area of 800 sq. ft. This capacity enables the user to install it in a large room or lounge.

Secondly, for safety purposes, there is an auto shut-off timer function. Moreover, you can use its flame function in summers by turning off the heating unit. Thirdly, the energy-efficient heating unit will help you to cut your electricity bills.

Why It Stands Out To Us?

The reason for standing out is the ambiance it provides to the room. The three different flame colors can be adjusted according to 5 different brightness settings. Also, the flames can be portrayed in a rising and downfall way. Furthermore, there is an option of automatic light effects with burning embers. Hence, great for serving as a night light and providing beauty to the room.

  • Beautiful traditional look and design.
  • 89000 BTU’s heater.
  • 3 flame colors with adjustable brightness.
  • Thermostat for temperature control.
  • Easy to install and operate.
  • Logs are not real-looking.


2. R.W.FLAME 36″ Electric Fireplace Insert (Runner Up)

This unit is a runner up for best rated electric fireplace insert. The metal insert has beautiful glass doors that provide an esthetic look. It can also heat up 400 sq. ft. area and hence great for small places and rooms. For energy saving purposes, you can alter the voltage from the standard one.

The flames are also great for providing a calming ambiance. There are 4 different speed settings and brightness levels available to enable the user to maintain the atmosphere according to the atmosphere. You can also switch all the flames off and use the heater only for cutting down the electricity bills.

Why It Stands Out To Us?

The reason for standing out is the various modern features it provides. For Example, multiple operation modes including touch screen and remote control, timer function, and temperature adjustment. Also, it is straightforward to install, but you’ll need professional assistance.

  • Stylish design including glass doors.
  • Multiple flame colors with adjustable speed.
  • Color changing feature.
  • Energy-efficient unit.
  • Certified by ETL as a safe unit.
  • Suitable for supplemental heating only.


3. SIMPLIFIRE 30-Inch Built-in Electric Fireplace (Best Look)

The third product on our list is SIMPLIFIRE built-in insert which is best in terms of its look. The front panel of the unit is made up of glass which gives a pleasing look. Also, the flames displaying from the glass front looks authentic and real looking logs add more to the beauty.

Also, the fireplace is excellent for cutting down electricity bills because of different energy input ways. The remote control for operation and realistic LED effects make this fireplace worth buy.

Why It Stands Out To Us?
The main reason for standing out is the multifunctional heating unit. It can throw 5,000 BTUs or 10,000 BTUs if the power supply is 120V or 240V respectively. This will be particularly helpful as you can switch to a high heat setting at the time of snowfall while low at others. Hence, the control will be in your hand.

  • The front glass screen provides an esthetic look.
  • Easy to operate with a remote.
  • Energy-efficient as voltage can be altered.
  • Beautiful rising flames.
  • Can be installed anywhere easily.
  • A bit pricey unit.


4. Napoleon Built-In Electric Firebox (Best Flame Effects)

Napoleon built-in electric firebox is among the best rated electric fireplace insert in terms of beauty and realistic flame effects. There are several color options with changing brightness, speed and impact.

Also, there are fading logs present on the ember bed for beautiful aesthetics.  Also, there are multiple modes of installing the unit. Besides the built-in process, you can place this unit in the wall and plug it in the cord. Moreover, it is effortless to operate because of the remote control. Overall, another excellent choice for enhancing the look of your room.

Why It Stands Out To Us?
The main reason for standing out is the esthetic look it provides. The front panel is made up of glass which is much pleasing to the eyes. Also, the LED technology portrays realistic flames which are very attractive. For another décor, you can buy a mantle and install the fireplace in it.

  • Beautiful night light effects.
  • The adjustable heat setting.
  • Convenient control modes.
  • Actual looking flame effects.
  • Multiple installation methods.
  • The price of the unit is a bit high.
  • (But remember, quality comes with a price)


5. Dimplex 42 Inch Built-in Electric Fireplace

Imagine the perfect fireplace with a clear, unobstructed view of dazzling flames a grand log set and a full herringbone brick surround. The Dimplex insert provides you with these features. It redefines the modern fireplace by giving you the look of a combustion fireplace with unique customization and simplicity. 
This fireplace is available as a built-in electric firebox for custom installations and a plug-in electric log set to bring your existing fireplace to life. Yet another best addition as the best-rated electric fireplace insert.

Why It Stands Out To Us?
The main reason for standing out is the premium quality of the electric fireplace insert. This product embodies Revillusion Flame Technology for the perfect look of flames. Also, the acrylic front panel portrays a beautiful view of LED effects.

  • 8794 BTU’s heater.
  • No hassle of venting.
  • Remote control for convenience.
  • Enchanting flame effects.
  • Easy to install the unit.
  • Limited warranty time range.


5 Best Plug-In Electric Fireplace Insert Reviews

Compared to build-in fireplace inserts, plug-in inserts are more comfortable and convenient to use. The reason is their installation is hassle-free, and they’re just like plug and play model. The price range is also moderate, and you can add them to your home for a warming ambiance. Here are reviews of some most realistic electric fireplace insert that you can try to add beauty to your room.


1. PuraFlame Western Electric Fireplace Insert (Overall Best Plug-in Unit)

The ventless PuraFlame insert is our top priority among the plug-in inserts. The unit’s front panel is made up of tempered glass, which provides a realistic look of logs and flames burning. Also, the flame settings can be adjusted according to your needs for enchanting ambiance.

The unit is also easy to install. It’s up to that either you recess it in-wall or place it in a mantle. In both cases, make sure to measure accurately as the back of this unit is a trapezoid. You can also check our ultimate guide for ease in the measuring process.

Why It Stands Out To Us?

The reason for standing out is its efficient heating capacity. It is a 4600 BTU’s heater which can heat up an area of 400 sq. ft. Also, you can operate it in two settings, i.e., 750W and 1500W. Hence, an energy-efficient unit to check.

  • Variable flame intensity.
  • Best for supplemental heating.
  • Built-in timer and thermostat.
  • Multiple installation modes.
  • Convenient to install and operate.
  • Cannot be hard-wired (Plug-in only).


2. R.W.FLAME 32″ Electric Fireplace Insert (Runner-Up)

It is the runner up unit and another best rated electric fireplace insert. The heating capacity of the fireplace is 400sq. Ft and the dancing flame effect completes the product. There are different flame options and adjustments available, like changing color and intensity.

Different heat options are also available for using the power of your choice and saving electricity. The built-in timer, thermostat, and remote control also play an essential part in making it the best unit.

Why It Stands Out To Us?

The reason for standing out is the alluring beauty of the unit. It is mainly composed of metal, but the front panel is made up of glass, which is best for flame esthetics. Also, the interior sidewalls are given bricks’ appearance while providing a contemporary and traditional design to the overall fireplace. 

  • Good heating capacity.
  • 5 flame and log effects modes.
  • Quiet unit (less than 38db).
  • ETL certified.
  • Convenient to use and install.
  • Flames do not rise high.


3. Classic Flame 3D Infrared Quartz Electric Fireplace (Best for Large Spaces)

The third choice for the best rated electric fireplace insert is a Classic Flame 3D fireplace. The fireplace contains many flame effects, including spectrafire, sapphire, amethyst, and others to ensure bright dancing flame effects.

Also, the heating element of the fireplace is infrared. That means that the unit will cut down your electricity bill and will save energy. The method of plugging in the product is also safe because of patent plugging technology. That means that unit will switch off in case of any electricity shortfall or any other issue.

Why It Stands Out To Us?

The main reason for standing out is the extensive heating capability. Generally, most of the fireplace units are meant for supplemental heating and heat up an area of 400 sq. ft. But the 5,200 BTU’s heater of this fireplace can heat up an area of 1000 sq. ft. Hence suitable for large rooms and lounge.

  • 3D realistic flame effects.
  • Easy to install (Just need to plug-in).
  • Infrared technology to maintain humidity.
  • Capable of large heat areas.
  • ETL certified fireplace.
  • The price is a bit high. (But worth the product).


4. Valuxhome 30 Inches Electric Fireplace Insert (Multifunctional Unit)

This multifunctional unit is another best rated electric fireplace insert. The distinctive feature is that the fireplace can gradually add heat to the room without overheating due to blower protection. Also, the blower is quiet and won’t disturb you while heating.

Furthermore, the unit is energy-efficient, and a built-in timer and remote control will ease down the process of using. With the help of a thermostat, you can change the temperature as per your needs and the outer atmosphere.

Why It Stands Out To Us?
The reason for standing out is the calming ambiance it provides. The flickering flame effects are comprised of 3 colors with adjustable settings. You can change the brightness of the flames up to 5 levels. Also, the crackling sound effects give the feel of a traditional fireplace.

  • Adjustable heat settings.
  • Built-in timer function.
  • 3 flame colors (Light orange, blue and purple).
  • Convenient to install (Plug-in unit).
  • Easy to operate (Remote Control).
  • Not suitable for large rooms.


5.Giantex 28.5″ Electric Fireplace Insert (Also Noteworthy)

Giantex 28.5″ Electric Fireplace is another noteworthy unit and best rated electric fireplace insert. The durable LED lights allow for a realistic flickering flame effect. You can also adjust the brightness of the flame through its incorporated control system according to your needs.

Also, the built-in user-friendly adjustable thermostat and safety thermal overload protector adds to this fireplace’s unique benefits. The fireplace, thus, allows you to regulate the heat as per your convenience.

Why It Stands Out To Us?

The reason for standing out is the overall incredible quality of the fireplace. It can render supplemental heat up an area of 400 sq. ft. Furthermore, the remote control helps you to operate the unit from anywhere in your room. Overall, it a worth buy and the best electric fireplace insert for heat.

  • Multiple installation methods.
  • Built-in timer function.
  • Thermostat for temperature maintenance.
  • Overheating protection.
  • ETL certified.
  • For supplemental heating only.


5 Best Electric Fire Log Insert Reviews

Fireplace logs are the most exciting option among the best rated electric fireplace insert. The reason is that they can be used in the insert as well as an outdoor unit giving a calming ambiance to the room.

For further details on outdoor fireplace options and ideas, you can have a look at:
Best Outdoor Electric Fireplace Ideas


1. Duraflame DFI021ARU Electric Log Set Heater (Best Of The Best)

Among electric fireplace logs, our top recommendation is Duraflame DFI021ARU Electric Log Set Heater. It is great for adding heat and beauty to the room.

An important feature is the rising flame effects with an ember bed. They look like real flames and enhance the look of the room. There is the reflective mechanism of LED lights, which results in a realistic flame effect. These effects are great for adding a warming ambiance to your room.

Why It Stands Out To Us?

The main reason for standing out is the best quality of the electric fireplace insert. It’s a 1400W heater capable of throwing 46,000 BTU’s. The built-in timer function of the fireplace and efficient thermostat ensure the best working. Also, it is excellent for adding flickering fire effects. 

  • High heat output.
  • Flickering flame effects.
  • Budget-friendly.
  • Long-Lasting.
  • Thermostat for temperature adjustment.
  • Slight humming noises.


2. Dimplex Firebox 23″ Insert (Runner Up)

This product is a runner-up in the best electric fireplace insert for heat. It carries a beautiful finish, and the fireplace’s flame effect is so realistic; you could come off to think of it as real logs are burning inside. The heating capacity is also adequate and an excellent product to check.

The product is equipped with an efficient thermostat that allows the user to set the fireplace comfortably. Also, its 12-hour on-off timer can be set to preheat a room and will automatically turn the heater off after a certain amount of time according to your ease.

Why It Stands Out To Us?

The main reason for standing out is the ease of installation. The process is straightforward, and you only need to plug it into any standard household outlet, and it is done! Also, power consumption is less. It just consumes some watts of power and thus saves a lot of energy.

  • Allow discrete styling.
  • High heating capacity.
  • Real looking effects.
  • Convenient to install and use.
  • Comes with a thermostat for temperature adjustment.
  • Auto on/off function for safety.
  • A bit noisy.


3. Dimplex Revillusion 20″ Plug-In Log Set (Also Noteworthy)

This fireplace is also noteworthy among the best rated electric fireplace insert because of its unique features. It can be installed anywhere in a room, lounge, or office and complement the modern décor. But you need to check the outlet location. 

Also, the price of the unit is affordable, and the heating capacity is also great. The burning flames of the unit, along with the logs, make up a beautiful scene. You can place it anywhere in your room and enjoy the soothing warm air.

Why It Stands Out To Us?
The reason for standing out is its versatility. The amount of warming it gives off is top-notch, and this heat will come in handy to heat most any room on a chilly night. Another wonderful thing is that you can look and feel a fireplace without the work and mess. The Dimplex fireplace inserts come with a thermostat that will help you keep a pleasant temperature in your room.

  • Fancy look.
  • No assembly required.
  • Hassle-free installation process.
  • Excellent and unique flame effects.
  • Suitable for large rooms.
  • Safe to use.
  • Sound effects are not included.


4. TURBRO Eternal Flame EF23-LG Electric Fireplace Logs

TURBRO Eternal Flame EF23-LG Electric Fireplace Logs

This best rated electric fireplace insert is another excellent unit to add beauty and warmth to your lounge or living room. The heating capacity is noteworthy of about 4777 BTU’s. The heat capacity is also adjustable and can be changed according to your needs according to the outer atmosphere.

The flame effects are also quite realistic. They emerge from the flame beds and start dispersing at the top give an eye-catching look and intrinsic warmth. Hence, soothing and pleasing to look at.

Why It Stands Out To Us?
The main reason for standing out is energy efficiency. It is an energy-efficient fireplace that can run on 1400W. It will help with a significant decline in your electricity bills, and for additional saving, you can alter the fireplace’s temperature through the thermostat according to your needs.

  • Convenient to operate and install.
  • Bright LED flames.
  • Adjustable flame brightness.
  • Multifunctional.
  • Easy to use with remote.
  • CSA certified.
  • 48 dB sound (Can be ignored).


5.Dimplex Revillusion 25″ Plug-In Log Set

Our last recommendation for the best rated electric fireplace insert is Dimplex Revillusion 25″ Plug-In Log Set. With an enchanting design and beautiful flame effects, it a worth buy. Also, it is equipped with all safety essentials to ensure the best experience.

Furthermore, the unit is energy-efficient, and a built-in timer and remote control will complete the process. With a thermostat, you can change the temperature as per your needs and the room’s condition.

Why It Stands Out To Us?
The reason for standing out is the beautiful flickering flame effects. These effects can add a calming ambiance as well as beauty to your room. So, get cozy these winters by using this best rated electric fireplace insert.

  • Capable of heating a large area.
  • Energy-efficient electric fireplace.
  • Beautiful flame glow.
  • Safe to use.
  • No hassle of installation (Ready to use).
  • A bit pricey unit.


Concluding Remarks

So, while concluding our discussion, we would like to say that there are plenty of available electric fireplace inserts that include built-in, plug-in and electric log sets. But the main point to understand is your demands. You need to check which product caters to your needs adequately.

A smart choice can be electric fireplace logs because they can also be used as an outdoor option. But built-in are great for providing noteworthy heat and plug-in units for esthetics. Duraflame DFI021ARU Electric Log Set Heater can be the right choice as per our recommendation. But, check your requirements properly and choose the best rated electric fireplace insert for you.

Leave a Comment